Showing posts with label Mitch Miller. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Mitch Miller. Show all posts

Thursday, September 30, 2010

A Dying Past

LeTourneau Organ, Hodge Chapel, Beeson School of Divinity, Samford University

I keep getting surprised by death.

No, not the concept but the fact that someone has died whom I had already presumed to be departed.

Some months ago it was Mitch Miller. (See August 3, 2010 blog.) More recently it was Eddie Fisher. I think that since Elizabeth has had so many very publicly traumatic health encounters, I had assumed that he had slipped quietly away some time ago. Aside from his marital histrionics, I didn’t know too much about him. I am aware of the “spacey” daughter. (You can read into that anything you wish.)

I was also surprised by death this week to learn the loss of an old mentor from college days. H. Edward Tibbs, a brilliant organist, designer of over 50 area organs, and excellent teacher, died in Birmingham. He was a great influence in my musical training.

However, I did not represent one of his great achievements.

I arrived as a transfer student to study church music at Howard College – now known as Samford University – with all the skepticism that a relatively large secular state university could imprint on a small-town boy. Couple that with the “worldliness” of having been under the spell of Paris-trained architects since leaving home too young and you have a cynical pseudo-sophisticate naïve teenager who was full of himself and the “international style.”

The state university campus had evolved with no apparent long-range plan. Remember that state universities expand on the lowest-bidder formula – edging a building spot wherever possible. Howard, however, was a model of planning – a collection of updated 18th Century design plopped down in the heart of Birmingham’s wealthiest area. Seas of limestone-clad towers, beveled glass, brass, and hand-rubbed paneling preening on a manicured landscape. Think William Graves Perry and Colonial Williamsburg without the sheep.

I arrived in this scenario of order and discipline with something of an attitude, I fear.


In order to be admitted to the music department, I had to play an audition. This was the second hurdle in this change of life plan. The first was telling my mother and father that not only was I not going to be an architect, I was also going to leave the relative inexpensive world of the state university to transfer to a private college in another town.

The plan unfolded, publicly, over Thanksgiving in my third year of design. It had been forming since I had begun to direct the choir at the Baptist church in the community where I lived. I was bitten by the music bug and it was gnawing away at my architecture

Being absorbed into the world of building design, I had not studied with a teacher in several years at this point. I contacted my old piano instructor from my youth to assist me with polishing my performance. I learned, later, that it was a “black day” for her. She was at once faced with the memories of a “less than dedicated” student who opted to drop out of lessons every other year. “Why is he tormenting me now?”

I had managed to prepare two Bach inventions and a Mozart Rondo. I actually surprised her and we had fun “polishing” the product. Only later did I learn about the “black day.”

Because I had a vision that I would spend my years as a church musician, on the order of J.S., himself, I decided I would be an organ major. Not good! Not good!

While I loved the organ, I was not “in love” with it. Even today, my playing is barely acceptable and my technique deplorable. Up to that point, my association with the instrument had been via an electronic device made popular by Ethel Smith and her famous Tico Tico. Hardly anything promising for someone expected to master the "St. Anne." Even Albert Schweitzer carved a better association with the instrument in the remote jungle. His tempos were a bit slow. It was probably the heat.

Page McPherson, on the other hand, was its most devoted follower. Her devotion could probably be characterized as obsession. She was our supreme “organista.”

You have all met a “Page” at some point in your life.

She was frighteningly dedicated. Physically, she was not a winsome wonder – rather plain. My friend, Steven Sparks, would have referred to her as a “woman of rare beauty.” But Page was in love with the organ.

She even had a special language which was associated with her grand passion: “HE” was Harold Gleason, the author of the “Bible” of organ-methodology. “SHE” was Catherine Crozier – married to Harold – who was one of the great organists of the day. “IT” was the large Aeolian-Skinner instrument in the chapel on the Howard campus. “HIM” was, of course, Tibbs, her teacher and mine.

Like the postman in the famous weather adage, Page walked the distance from the music department over to the chapel many times each day with her “Orgelbuchlien” clutched against her chest. She was not a shapely girl so I chose not to use bosum. And because of her limited lexicon, she was not particularly popular. It is hard to fake interest in a discussion with that many pronouns. You get confused easily.

My lessons were always traumatic. I practiced, but refused to own those special male tap-dancing shoes that were required for excellent pedal technique. My “chukka” boots just didn’t hack it. I would forget to lift the inner fingers on the repeated notes. Dealing with me was a challenge for Tibbs. I should have shared the contact information for my piano teacher of childhood so they could commiserate together. They could have compared "black days."

Eventually Tibbs and I had a meeting of the minds. I became a voice major. You don’t need special shoes for that.

Page continued her devotion.

One fine spring day after I had come to my senses and dropped my organ career, everyone was in a “forget practicing and let’s goof off” mood. The windows of the music building were open and you could hear competing melodies. Coming from up in the garret was the sound of Page slaving away on the “Little G-minor" on the Holtkamp.

It was April and 50 years almost to the day of that riotous premiere in Paris. You know the one. A light went on in my rambunctious mind.

I coerced a couple of buddies to assist me. We dashed upstairs as the strains of “Le Sacre du Printemps” was being blasted out an open window and grabbed Page from her perch on the organ bench. We opened the garret window – three stories up – and bodily dangled Page headfirst as our virginal sacrifice to spring as Stravinsky’s pulsating ostinatos hit their peak.

Yes it was cruel, But it was Spring! April is, after all, "the cruellest month."

While she screamed protests, she smiled the rest of the month of April and even into May for all the attention she received. She, he, and him would have been proud of her!.

While I was a disaster as an organ major, Tibbs taught me a ton about sacred music. I learned about the practice of music in varied faiths. I developed quite a love of contemporary organ literature – especially Dupré, Langlais, and Messiaen. He taught me the fundamentals of organ design. I even became a better composer because I understood “the king of instruments.” Who knows what might have happened if I had those tap shoes.

So a great "thank you" to HIM!

Tony Curtis died today.

While we were not particularly close, the past keeps leaving me.

Tuesday, August 3, 2010

Mitch, We Hardly Knew Ye

Mitch Miller died Monday. He was 99. Truth be told, I thought he died years ago. I think I must have confused him with Mantovani, another of those who took music to the mainstream.

Mitch was the one with the goatee. Mantovani was Italian. Leonard Berstein was talented, but such a mess of emotion when he conducted. Miller seemed, as I recall, "cool."

While I may have hummed, I don’t think that I ever “Sang Along With Mitch.” I know some folks who did and they didn’t seem worse for the wear. Mitch’s music was not exceptional or complicated; there were no challenging harmonies; it was after all, unison sing-a-long.

Despite the simplicity of it, I did call upon Mitch a lot over the years. Maybe not “call upon” but evoke him.

You see, I have conducted a volunteer church choir since I was around 14. Yes, that is correct. I was a precocious nerd. The Baptist’s were in need and I answered their plea. This was along about the time when my father decided that our family was going to go to church together rather than roast in hell. Up to that signal event, his weekly Sunday “headache” had put our souls in peril. But that was an earlier blog.

Invariably volunteer choirs are small. That is, unless you are in a large mega-church, and then they are large and sloppy and sound a lot like a Mitch Miller group except for the “Blood of the Lamb” part. Mitch usually dealt with the Bossa Nova. I think the Astrud Gilburto, “Girl from Ipanema” was far too-wordy for Mitch to tackle, but I could be wrong.

So back to the volunteer choir.

Most volunteer choirs have been garnered through a lot of coercion and applied guilt. Growing up as a Baptist, I know volumes about applied guilt. Only in about 23.8 percent of the cases of “volunteerism” does the singer actually come forward and proclaim, “I want desperately to sing in the choir. I have a passion to do so.”

Many years ago, I had an alto who had a passion for singing in the church choir. She also had a great talent for being “way off pitch.” Her passion was so great that she never missed rehearsal or Sunday worship. She was friendly and the type to jump up and get a copy of music for another. But she was always a “tonal irritant.” But the choir was her outlet. The choir was her expression of her faith.

You just don’t mess with a person’s expression of faith.

With volunteers, you learn that you endure their faults and rejoice in their contributions. Mary Franklin filled a robe and a seat on the second row. She also contributed to my prayer life since week after week I pleaded, “Dear God, help MF to find the joy in arranging the altar flowers or being a greeter.” Had I had more of an entrepreneurial bent and had Mary Franklin more of a sense of humor, we could have pre-empted “Jonathan and Darlene Edwards” or gone “downtown” ahead of Mrs. Miller.

But, I digress.

With the 76.2 percent of the volunteer choir who have been recruited through coercion and guilt, they generally come with a sense of timidity.

Do you know how many times I have heard, “I only sing in the shower.”

We had a sprinkler system installed over the choir loft.

Over the years, I have often reminded my volunteers that 20 people singing sotto voce (half voice) does not garner the same effect as 80. Hence, the reference to Mitch. “Choir, this isn’t ‘sing along with Mitch time.’” I am big on mental images when I work with the choir. Ask my tenors and basses about Betty Lou and the St. Ignatius Boy Choir.

Oh, the mysterious ways of the volunteer choir.

I keep waiting for Susan Boyle to appear in my congregation and following a “rip roaring”sermon come forward and say the words that a choir director longs to hear.

“Would you have room for another singer in your choir?”

But since our sermons are more beige than “rip roaring,” I have to continue with the coercion and the guilt. Thankfully, my Baptist mother taught me well.

Years ago, I had a great teenage soprano who volunteered to sing in my Youth Choir which met on Sunday afternoon. She had an amazing young voice. However, I discovered soon afterwards that "choir" was a way to meet a rambunctuous boyfriend. Her mom would drop her off in front of the church and observe her enter the building. She missed her exit out the back.

While I could threaten to post something on the internet, I never would.

Rest in peace, Mitch.